Former constable candidate sues Williamson County commissioners


GEORGETOWN, Texas (KXAN) – Williamson County commissioners and the Williamson County Judge Dan Gattis are being sued for civil rights violations by a former candidate for an open constable position.

Robert Lloyd, a 27-year law enforcement veteran said he was asked about his views on abortion, gay marriage, religion, and who he voted for in the last electionduring an interview.

Such questions are illegal.

But that didn’t stop Williamson County commissioners from asking those very questions when they were interviewing candidates for the Precinct 3 constable vacancy.  And now, one of those candidates is suing them for violating his constitutional rights.

“This needs to stop. It’s ludicrous that this is happening,” Lloyd said.

In March, Lloyd was one of five candidates interviewed for the open Precinct 3 constable position in Williamson County.  He says the questions asked by county commissioners took him by surprise.

“The majority of the interview took place asking me what my political affiliation was, my views on abortion, my views on gay marriage, long conversation about my religion,” Lloyd claimed.

Lloyd’s attorneys with the Texas Civil Rights Project say those questions are illegal.  In a lawsuit filed Monday, Lloyd recounts his answer when he was asked that question about his position on gay marriage.

“I gave the best answer that I felt that I could with the knowledge that the world is changing, people are changing, the US supreme court looks at these cases every day,” Lloyd said.

According to Lloyd, and the lawsuit, one commissioner responded by saying, “If you are appointed as constable, you better come up with a better answer than that.”

“This is so clearly a violation of both federal and state law,” said Jim Harrington with the Texas Civil Rights Project.

Harrington says not only is this is a clear violation of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution but also The Texas Bill of Rights, which states “no religious test should ever be required as a qualification to any office.”

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission rules state: “an employer may not base hiring decisions on stereotypes and assumptions about a person’s race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability or genetic information.”

When asked about the interview questions in May, Williamson County Precinct 3 Commissioner Valerie Covey said those rules don’t apply in this situation.

“In general, this is a process that is different than a normal employment interview because it is an elected position,” Covey said.

When KXAN first reported this story in May, Covey was the only person on the commissioners court to agree to an on-camera interview.

“We wanted to make sure the candidate could not only do the job as constable, but also handle the rigor of political life,” Covey said.

Lloyd’s attorneys also obtained handwritten notes taken by one commissioner during the interview process.

“You can see that they actually took notes about gay marriage and abortion responses and noted that in their political, religious opinion, that his response was not definitive,” said Wayne Krause Yang.  “So you can see that this actually affected his ability to be a constable.”

Lloyd says he’s not asking for money from the lawsuit.

“My only drive in this is that I want it to be made public, and I want it to be corrected,” he said.

Two other candidates for the constable position are also joining this lawsuit, according to lawyers with the Texas Civil Rights Project. The group has also filed a criminal complaint with the Williamson County District Attorney’s office, asking for a criminal investigation.

KXAN reached out to each of the Williamson County commissioners on Monday and had not received any response to the lawsuit. provides commenting to allow for constructive discussion on the stories we cover. In order to comment here, you acknowledge you have read and agreed to our Terms of Service. Users who violate these terms, including use of vulgar language or racial slurs, will be banned. Please be respectful of the opinions of others. If you see an inappropriate comment, please flag it for our moderators to review.

  • Eye on Williamson » Controversy Continues With Precinct 3 Constable Hiring

    […] It looks like Stofle – who was then the Asst. Chief of Police in Georgetown – didn’t want his neighbor, who was likely driving drunk with her 7 year old child, being charged with DWI after leaving his wife’s birthday party. Although he denies it. It comes down to his word, over that of the DPS officer in the report. The commissioners obviously took him at this word. Maybe acting like your above the law isn’t a disqualifier for the job. As long as you’re in the right political party and have the right stands on the issues. […]

  • Eye on Williamson » Democrats Pressure County To Settle Lawsuit

    […] The commissioners are being sued for civil rights violations, Former constable candidate sues Williamson County commissioners. […]

  • Williamson Co. job candidates asked about gay marriage, abortion |

    […] Lloyd says his lawsuit could have a big impact on anyone applying for a public service job. He has since been joined by plaintiffs Robert Goodrich and Fred Churchill who allege similar interview experiences. […]

blog comments powered by Disqus